Who Wants to Be A Millionaire?

The other day I mused about how to be a millionaire, but today I’m reeling the conversation one step back: SHOULD you want to be a millionaire?

Many people think you shouldn’t. Many say chasing a million dollars won’t make you wealthy.

The problem is that $1 million is an arbitrary figure, plucked from thin air.who wants to be a millionaire

What’s so magical about $1 million dollars? Will it buy a sprawling mansion in the Hollywood Hills? (Nope). Will it promise financial security? (Nope). Will our lives change between the day we have $950,000 and the day we cross the $1 million mark? (Probably not.)

Many people believe that instead of chasing $1 million dollars, you should focus on chasing “passive income” – a term that means “money you get while sitting on your butt.”

I (sort of) disagree. Passive income IS the ultimate goal, but aspiring to be a millionaire can get you there. Follow my logic here …

Motivate Me to $1 Million …

Passive income, for those of you who have never heard that term, is money that you make without lifting a finger. It could be money your investments earn, or money rolling in from royalties, or rental income on a house that you’re hired someone else to manage.

Passive income is the true yardstick of wealth. Once you earn enough passive income to pay your bills, you’re financially “free.” You’ll never have to work again unless you want to.

But it can be tough to calculate exactly how much you’ll need in order to reach financial freedom. All of those calculations are built on assumptions – how much will the stock market return? How long will my rental property sit vacant?

Once you calculate a number, it’ll most likely be an odd figure: $1,147,807 for some people, or $987,243 for others.

Psychologically, it’s tough to get pumped for a savings goal of $987,000 or $1.14 million.

Imagine that your goal is to watch your brokerage account cross from five digits to six. You’ve got $99,600 in investments. You need only $400 more until you hit six figures. You’ll be pumped to earn and save that cash. Who wouldn’t?

Now imagine that your goal is to have $94,000 in your account, and you currently have $93,600. You’ll need to earn and save the same $400 to achieve your goal, but your motivation won’t be as strong. The “reward feeling” just won’t be the same.who wants to be a millionaire

The brain responds to symbolic hallmarks. That’s why dropping from a weight of 201 pounds to 199 pounds feels like a large victory (no pun intended). That’s why improving your grades from B+ to A- feels like a huge boost.

In reality, you’ve only lost 2 pounds in weight or gained 2 points in your test scores. But the feeling of victory makes those 2 pounds, or those 2 test score points, a cause for celebration.

And that feeling is ultimately what keeps you motivated.

So maybe I’ll only need $987,000 to create enough passive income to pay my bills. Maybe I’ll need $1.14 million, or $1.23 million, or $1.76 million. But none of those numbers are going to motivate me.

You know what will motivate me? Watching my brokerage account cross from six digits to seven.

Isn’t Passive Income Enough of a Goal?

Some might argue that you could motivate yourself through a goal of hitting a ‘passive income’ hallmark – say, $40,000 a year in passive income.

The problem is that this is a secondary goal. To achieve it, you need to take an immediate action and then wait for a long-term result.

Let’s say you currently make $19,800 in passive income and your goal is to make $20,000. First, you’ll have to crunch some numbers (translation: guess) to figure out how much you’d need to save to create that extra $200 in passive income. Then you’ll need to contribute that guessed-number into your investment account. Then you’ll be forced to wait and see whether or not you’ll reap the predicted consequence.

This guesswork and “lag time” is a de-motivator. It’s better when your motivation comes from the immediate, tangible action itself.

That’s why wanting to feel energized (immediate) or lose weight (moderately immediate) are more motivating reasons to exercise than wanting to reduce the number of days you feel sick next winter (long-term result).

What Can $1 Million Buy?

Okay, so let’s imagine that you ultimately want passive income, but you decide to set a goal of investing $1 million dollars. What will that yield you?

For the sake of example, let’s look at the real-life numbers of Vanguard’s Dividend Growth Fund (VDIGX).who wants to be a millionaire? stock market

You invest $1 million into this fund. You live on the dividends, which average 3 percent each year, or $30,000 dollars. This is your “passive income.”

Although you’re living on the dividends, you’re reinvesting the gains. This fund grew at a yearly average of 7 percent since 1992 – some years less, some years more. Of course, most of that growth happened in the 1990’s, when the markets were on a winning streak. In the past 10 years, it only returned a 4 percent average.

Let’s look at the worst-case scenario: You invested your $1 million in summer 2001, just before the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks, the dot-com burst, and the subsequent stock market crash. By 2003, your $1 million dwindled to $640,000.

But don’t worry: your money more than doubled during the next 4 years. Then it crashed in 2007-08, losing half its value. Then it doubled again in 2009-10. It’s been a bumpy ride.

The $1 million you invested at the start of the worst decade since the Great Depression would be worth $1.4 million today. This outpaces inflation, which was about 2.3 percent over the past decade ($1 million a decade ago is $1.23 million today).

That $1.4 million in your fund today, earning 3 percent dividends, now gives you $42,000 in passive income – a nice “raise” you earn for doing nothing.

Of course, this balances out the “lean years” when your investments tanked and your dividends earned only $19,200. You budget for $30,000 a year and you save any “raises” to cushion the lean years.

I’m getting a little too mired in the numbers here, so let’s pull back and make the broader point: it’s easier to motivate yourself to create $1 million than to create passive income. And the result will be the same: Hitting a $1 million goal can produce the passive income that ultimately sets you financially free.

Speaking of being motivated by a symbolic hallmark: I have 97 Facebook “Likes”. Please help me hit 101 today! :-)

Free Tips on Affording Anything:



Screenshot taken from Vanguard.com

Tags:

32 Responses to “Who Wants to Be A Millionaire?”

  1. Art Shunk
    24. Aug, 2011 at 11:29 am #

    The dividends should not necessarily go down when the market value does. Since the fund is distributing the underlying dividends, the yield should just increase when the price drops(not accounting for dividend cuts).

    • AffordAnything.org
      24. Aug, 2011 at 5:00 pm #

      @Art Shrunk — Hey, cool!! I thought the dividend yield rate is fixed (unless the company announces a cut or a raise) … wow, a variable yield rate. Sweet!!

  2. Kevin @ Thousandaire.com
    24. Aug, 2011 at 12:18 pm #

    I want to have $1 million because then I’ll win my race with The Hoff!

    I actually agree with you that passive income is the true goal of becoming wealthy.

  3. cashflowmantra
    24. Aug, 2011 at 12:42 pm #

    I also agree that passive income and financial freedom is really what most people seek when they want to be a millionaire. But there is something about that psychological hurdle. I am working on the below 200 one myself.

    • AffordAnything.org
      24. Aug, 2011 at 5:05 pm #

      @cashflowmantra — Good luck!! I lost quite a lot of weight after college (a lady never reveals her numbers!) and I remember the HUGE psychological victory of dropping into the lower “set of 10″ (as in, 140 to 139, or from 130 to 129, or from 120 to 119). One of my best friends recently lost 60 pounds and she said the same thing … every time she reached a new “set of 10″ she won a big victory, even though it was really just a 1 pound difference. Keep us posted!!

  4. femmefrugality
    24. Aug, 2011 at 12:53 pm #

    Numbers absolutely motivate me a heck of a lot better, as well. The biggest problem I’m having? Figuring out what those numbers should be. As in how much do I need/want…how do I set those goals.

  5. The Money Grower
    24. Aug, 2011 at 2:23 pm #

    @ femmefrugality

    “The biggest problem I’m having? Figuring out what those numbers should be. As in how much do I need/want…how do I set those goals.”

    Something just out of your reach. Then when you achieve it, change your goal?

  6. The Money Grower
    24. Aug, 2011 at 2:33 pm #

    oops, I forgot the point I was gonna make. The nominal value is really there to satify a psychological need.

    Let me ask you this question: who would be richer?

    1) A dollar millionaire in the US?

    2) A pound millionaire in the UK?

    3) A rupee millionaire in Nepal?

    (did you like that last one Paula, that was a nod to your heritage)

    Kevin, you’re definitely a nepalese millionaire – twice ove. How cool is that?

    TMG

    • AffordAnything.org
      24. Aug, 2011 at 4:57 pm #

      @The Money Grower — LOL!! I like that!! After I read your comment I wondered if I could ever be a Nepalese rupee BILLIONAIRE, but according to Google’s currency converter, that would require $13.76 million US dollars. Then I checked the Zimbabwe Dollar (after all, no one has runaway inflation the way Zimbabwe does!) to see if I could be a billionaire in Zimbabwe — but even that would require $2.76 million US dollars (or $1.6 million British pounds). Alas, no billionaire status for me.

  7. Miss T @ Prairie Eco-Thrifter
    24. Aug, 2011 at 2:44 pm #

    I agree. A firm goal like that is a lot easier to visualize than an opportunity. However, passive income is a great way to boost those savings.

  8. Doctor Stock
    24. Aug, 2011 at 2:49 pm #

    I agree with the principle… but I’m not sure the term “passive” always leads people to the right conclusions. I agree I want to make income based on my assets, enough to live on without requiring me to dip in to the capital. On the other hand, if it requires a little more “active” thought on my part, especially if the returns are that much greater, than I’m willing to do so. After all, if you could earn $40,000 passively or $80,000 with a little attention to your investments, I’d be active for the reward.

  9. Christa
    24. Aug, 2011 at 4:04 pm #

    I agree that moving from 6 figures to 7 is really motivating and must be a huge part of why so many people aim for a million. Great post!

    • AffordAnything.org
      24. Aug, 2011 at 4:49 pm #

      @Christa — Thanks!! Right now I’m just trying to move from 5 figures to 6 …. :-)

  10. krantcents
    24. Aug, 2011 at 4:35 pm #

    Most people would not wait to invest the million all at once. Over time the returns could be even greaterby dollar cost averaging into the market.

    • AffordAnything.org
      24. Aug, 2011 at 4:48 pm #

      @krantcents — True, that’s why it’s a worst-case scenario: You invest the whole amount, all at once, right before the market tanks, at the start of the worst investing decade of our lifetimes! Can’t get much more worst-case than that (unless you panic and sell at the bottom!)

  11. The Money Grower
    24. Aug, 2011 at 5:16 pm #

    Today, Paula, YOU are a BILLIONAIRE!

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Least_valued_currency_unit

    TMG

  12. Financial Samurai
    24. Aug, 2011 at 10:23 pm #

    The low CD and savings rates are really bumming me out. Can’t believe we need $4.5 million now to generate $100,000 in passive income!

    We can always try though!

    Best, Sam

  13. Lindy Mint
    25. Aug, 2011 at 4:31 pm #

    Hmm. This post has me thinking I need to set a goal that involves a lot more zeros. :)

    • AffordAnything.org
      25. Aug, 2011 at 5:00 pm #

      @Lindy Mint — LOL! Yeah — “Gee, my goal this month is to save $400 — er, $400.00 — um, I mean, $400.000000″ :-)

  14. Mike @ Credit Card Forum Blog
    25. Aug, 2011 at 6:59 pm #

    Regarding what Sam said above, yeah the unfortunate thing is with interest rates next to nothing on CDs, to earn a risk free return of $40k one would need a few million these days. The worst part is that since inflation outpaces the rates, you’re still losing money every year even if you never touch the principle :(

  15. World of Finance
    25. Aug, 2011 at 10:00 pm #

    You’re right, psychology plays a big role with numbers. For example, stores use prices like 3.95 or 3.99, even though it’s $4 (actually more than that with tax :P ) but 3 is less than 4 so it sounds cheaper and plays the psychological game.

  16. Cassandra
    27. Aug, 2011 at 12:14 am #

    “It’s easier to motivate yourself to create $1 million” This is really true, though it’s not about the money like in Jessie Jane’s song. I don’t understand but still a motivation is awaken. To spend it to what you dream of.

  17. Daniel
    04. Sep, 2011 at 12:54 am #

    I think psychologically it sounds good, but I also would espouse that having far smaller goals helps enable one to shoot for the bigger goals. For example paying off your house is a lofty goal for most people. However, once that goal is met, you will have more capital available to put toward greater goals.

  18. Alissa Fischer
    04. Dec, 2011 at 7:40 pm #

    I am working on the below 200 one myself. I agree I want to make income based on my assets, enough to live on without requiring me to dip in to the capital. Since the fund is distributing the underlying dividends, the yield should just increase when the price drops(not accounting for dividend cuts).

    • AffordAnything.org
      05. Dec, 2011 at 2:04 pm #

      @Alissa — Best of luck on the dropping-under-200 goal … please write back and let me know how it’s going! I’m cheering you on!

  19. bob
    01. Feb, 2012 at 10:54 pm #

    For many retiring at a young age would be boring however a low stress business that revolves around a passion or a hobby that doesn’t require the proprietor to be there 24/7 seems like a good goal. This semivactive income could come in the form of owning a real estate agency or car dealership for example and could provide living expense income as well as investment capital. Any thoughts on this approach?

    • AffordAnything.org
      02. Feb, 2012 at 10:41 am #

      @bob — Owning a real estate agency, a car dealership or any other business is a lot of work and responsibility, so the key is to only do it if you enjoy it.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Friday Round-Up | MomVesting - 26. Aug, 2011

    [...] at AffordAnything questions what a million dollar goal really [...]

  2. I Wanna Be a Billionaire! | Afford Anything .org - 31. Aug, 2011

    [...] week I wrote about the importance of aspiring to become a millionaire — even if your “real” goals are [...]

  3. Carnival of Wealth, Fall into Fall Edition | Control Your Cash: Making Money Make Sense - 12. Sep, 2011

    [...] able to find (or are interested in finding) jobs in retirement, this could be a way to go.Paula at Afford Anything doesn’t seem to understand that $ means “dollars” (“$1 million [...]

  4. 4 Surprising Truths You Must Learn Before You Can Be Rich « Len Penzo dot Com - 12. Oct, 2011

    [...] is psychological. Whether your goal is to become rich, lose 20 pounds or learn another language, your mindset is your strongest weapon. You are your own [...]

  5. Totally Money Carnival #36: Football Is Back Edition | Money Beagle - 14. Dec, 2011

    [...] @ AffordAnything.org presents Who Wants to Be A Millionaire? posted at [...]

Leave a Reply